Best payroll software for small business 2024

Rating 0.00 (0 Votes)

We test and review software products using an independent, multipoint methodology. If you purchase something through our links, we may earn a commission. Read about our editorial process.

Don't know which software to choose? Our experts are ready to help you

Papaya Global - review, pricing plans, alternatives

Papaya Global

3 Reviews
Official site
papayaglobal.com
Quick choice
Editor's Choice
Deel (Payroll) - review, pricing plans, alternatives, details

Deel (Payroll)

2 Reviews
Official site
deel.com/payroll
Quick choice
Most affordable
Oyster (Payroll) - review, pricing plans, alternatives

Oyster (Payroll)

2 Reviews
Official site
oysterhr.com/payroll
Quick choice
Most advanced
Sage (Payroll) - review, pricing plans, alternatives

Sage (Payroll)

1 Reviews
Official site
sage.com/payroll
Quick choice
Best price/quality
Buddy Punch (Payroll) - review, pricing plans, alternatives

Buddy Punch (Payroll)

1 Reviews
Official site
buddypunch.com/payroll
Quick choice
Best for beginners
KiwiHR (Payroll) - review, pricing plans, alternatives

KiwiHR (Payroll)

Leave review
Official site
kiwihr.com
Netchex (Payroll) - review, pricing plans, alternatives

Netchex (Payroll)

Leave review
Official site
netchex.com/payroll
Workable (Payroll) - review, pricing plans, alternatives

Workable (Payroll)

Leave review
Official site
workable.com
Remote (Payroll) - review, pricing plans, alternatives

Remote (Payroll)

Leave review
Official site
remote.com/payroll

Latest reviews

Patrick Bateman

Patrick Bateman on Buddy Punch (Payroll)

Buddy Punch is the top payroll software for small businesses in 2024 Its user-friendly interface makes managing payroll a breeze saving time and reduc...
George Liddy

George Liddy on Sage (Payroll)

Sage stands out as the best payroll software for small businesses in 2024 Its user-friendly interface simplifies payroll management and saves valuable...
Jason Wayne

Jason Wayne on Oyster (Payroll)

Oyster stands out as the best payroll software for small businesses in 2024 Its user-friendly interface simplifies payroll management allowing busines...
Lillian Rose

Lillian Rose on Oyster (Payroll)

Oyster is an exceptional payroll software for small businesses in 2024. Its intuitive interface simplifies payroll processing and ensures compliance w...
Jonatan Leandoer

Jonatan Leandoer on Deel (Payroll)

Deel stands out as the best payroll software for small businesses in 2024 Its user-friendly interface simplifies payroll processing making it easy to ...
Liam Harris

Liam Harris on Deel (Payroll)

Deel stands out as the best payroll software for small businesses in 2024. Its user-friendly interface simplifies complex payroll tasks, making it eas...

How to choose best payroll software for small business 2024

When selecting payroll software for your small business, it’s essential to first evaluate your specific needs. Every company has unique requirements based on the size of the workforce, industry regulations, and budget.

Taking the time to understand these needs will help narrow down your options and ensure the software you choose aligns with your goals.

Identifying key features

To begin, identify the key features that are crucial for your payroll process. Basic functionalities like automatic payroll calculations, tax filing, and direct deposit are must-haves for most businesses.

Additionally, consider if your business requires more advanced options such as employee self-service portals, time tracking integrations, or benefits management. These features can streamline operations and improve efficiency.

Another important aspect is scalability. As your business grows, your payroll software should be able to handle increased employee numbers without sacrificing performance.

Evaluating user experience

User experience plays a significant role in payroll software selection. A simple, intuitive interface reduces the learning curve and helps your team get started quickly.

Check if the software offers customization options that allow you to tailor dashboards or reports according to your specific needs. A clean and well-organized design ensures smoother navigation and minimizes errors.

Also, consider mobile accessibility. If your payroll team works remotely or needs to access information on the go, a mobile-friendly or cloud-based solution may be a valuable asset.

Researching payroll software options

Once you’ve identified your business needs, the next step is researching different payroll software options available in the market. This involves comparing various solutions, taking into account pricing, user feedback, and feature sets to find the best fit for your company.

A thorough comparison ensures you make a well-informed decision, aligning the software with your budget and functional requirements.

Comparing pricing plans

Pricing is a critical factor when selecting payroll software, especially for small businesses with limited budgets. It’s important to compare different pricing structures, such as subscription-based plans, one-time fees, or tiered pricing based on the number of employees.

Look for any hidden costs, such as fees for additional users, customer support, or premium features. Consider whether the software offers a free trial or demo to test its functionalities before committing to a payment plan.

Some payroll solutions offer discounts for annual subscriptions, which can be cost-effective if you’re looking for long-term use.

Checking customer reviews and ratings

Customer reviews and ratings provide valuable insights into how well the software performs in real-world scenarios. Look for feedback on reliability, ease of use, and overall satisfaction. High ratings and positive reviews often indicate that the software delivers on its promises.

Pay attention to any recurring complaints or issues, especially regarding customer support, software glitches, or scalability challenges. This can help you avoid potential pitfalls in the future.

It’s also helpful to read reviews from businesses similar to yours, as their experiences may closely align with the needs of your company.

Ensuring compliance and security

When choosing payroll software, compliance with legal requirements and robust data security measures are critical factors. Payroll systems must handle sensitive employee information, so ensuring that your chosen software meets both regulatory standards and security protocols is essential.

A failure to comply with tax laws or secure employee data can lead to costly fines and damage to your business’s reputation.

Understanding legal requirements

Payroll software must adhere to local, state, and federal tax laws. Ensure the software is equipped to automatically update tax rates, calculate withholdings, and generate compliant tax forms. Staying up to date with changing regulations helps avoid penalties and ensures that your business operates within the law.

It’s also important to check whether the software supports compliance with specific labor laws, such as overtime pay calculations or worker classification. This is particularly crucial for industries with complex employment laws.

If your business operates in multiple regions, make sure the software can handle different tax jurisdictions and legal requirements without manual intervention.

Evaluating data security measures

Given the sensitive nature of payroll data, robust security protocols are non-negotiable. Check if the software uses encryption to protect data during transmission and storage, safeguarding personal and financial information from unauthorized access.

Additionally, look for features like multi-factor authentication (MFA) and role-based access controls. MFA adds an extra layer of security, ensuring only authorized users can access the payroll system. Role-based controls help restrict access to sensitive information based on the employee’s role within the company.

Regular security audits and automatic software updates further enhance protection, keeping the system secure from evolving threats.

Implementation and support

Successfully implementing payroll software requires a smooth onboarding process and reliable customer support. The right solution should offer a clear path for setting up the software, training your team, and ensuring ongoing support for any challenges that may arise.

Choosing a system with strong onboarding and support services can save your business time and prevent costly errors.

Understanding onboarding processes

When selecting payroll software, it’s important to understand the onboarding process. Some systems offer guided setup options, providing step-by-step instructions and tutorials that help new users get familiar with the software quickly. This is particularly helpful if your team has little experience with payroll systems.

Consider how long the implementation process will take, as some platforms may take days or weeks to fully integrate. The availability of data migration services is also essential, especially if you are switching from another system and need to transfer historical payroll records.

Training resources, such as webinars, user guides, or one-on-one consultations, can greatly ease the transition and help your staff utilize the software efficiently from the start.

Assessing customer support options

Reliable customer support is crucial, especially during the early stages of using new payroll software. Check if the provider offers multiple channels for support, such as live chat, phone support, or email, ensuring that you can get help quickly when needed.

24/7 support is particularly valuable for businesses that operate across different time zones or need assistance outside of standard business hours. Investigate the average response times and quality of support by reading user reviews or consulting with the provider.

Some payroll solutions also offer dedicated account managers or premium support options, which can be beneficial for complex payroll needs or larger teams requiring more personalized assistance.

Bottom line

Once you've narrowed down your options, the final step is to evaluate the cost versus the benefits and gather feedback from key stakeholders. This ensures that the payroll software you choose is not only affordable but also meets the practical needs of your business and team.

A well-rounded decision-making process will help you avoid issues down the line and ensure smooth implementation.

Analyzing cost vs. benefit

Before making a final decision, it's important to weigh the costs of the software against the benefits it provides. Consider the pricing structure, including any setup fees, subscription costs, or extra charges for additional features. Ensure that the software fits within your budget without compromising essential functionalities.

Next, assess the value the software brings to your business. Features that save time, automate processes, and reduce manual errors can justify a higher price, as they ultimately lead to increased efficiency and cost savings. Additionally, evaluate how the software will support your long-term growth, ensuring it can scale with your business.

Balancing cost with practical benefits ensures you get the best value for your investment without overpaying for features you don’t need.

Gathering feedback from stakeholders

Involving key stakeholders in the decision-making process is crucial for choosing the right payroll software. Gather input from your payroll team, HR department, and even employees who may interact with self-service portals. Their feedback on usability, essential features, and pain points can provide valuable insights that you might overlook.

It’s also beneficial to involve IT or data security teams to ensure the software meets technical requirements, especially regarding security and system integration. Their expertise can help identify potential challenges before implementation.

By considering the opinions and needs of all stakeholders, you ensure that the chosen solution will be well-received and effective across your organization.

When selecting payroll software, prioritize features such as automated tax calculations, employee self-service portals, direct deposit options, and compliance management. Additionally, look for integration capabilities with other accounting or HR software, as well as scalability to accommodate your business's growth.

Pricing for payroll software can vary widely depending on the features and number of employees. Generally, expect to pay between $20 to $100 per month for basic packages, with additional fees for extra features or higher employee counts. It's essential to evaluate your budget and consider both upfront and ongoing costs.

Yes, customer support is crucial when selecting payroll software, especially for small businesses that may not have dedicated HR personnel. Look for providers that offer responsive customer service through multiple channels, such as phone, email, and chat. Read reviews to gauge the quality of support and ensure assistance is available when you need it.

Filters
Quick choice
Editor's Choice
Most advanced
Most affordable
Best price/quality
Best for beginners
Rating